\”\”You can think of a rotating detonation engine as a type of pulse detonation engine — with a twist. This is a General Electric Frame 7FA gas turbine.Courtesy of General Electric Company
An engine designed for a ship isn\’t going to fit in a car … but automotive types tend to be intrigued by the latest technology in bangs and booms. After all, an engine is an engine, capable of immense power (and who knows when such innovations will trickle down to the civilian sector).
So with that in mind, let\’s look at the rotating detonation engine — a type of gas-turbine that\’s designed for efficiency, with its carefully constructed, consistent cycle of injections and explosions. It\’s not exactly new — the patent was awarded about 20 years ago — but as of late 2012, it\’s just now scratching the surface of its potential to generate power for large modes of transportation.
Researchers say the rotating detonation engine could also be adapted to generate electric power for all-electric ships and planes … once we\’re advanced enough to have reliable boats and aircraft driven primarily by electricity, that is.
The United States military chose to invest in the rotating detonation engine\’s research and development, in part, because the technology is easily scaleable — the size of the engine can be increased, and power production will also be increased. (Believe it or not, it doesn\’t always work that way.) So we never know — perhaps the rotating detonation engine can be scaled down someday and its smooth power generation can propel all types of rolling stock.
We tend to think of the pressures created inside an engine as being more controlled rather than disorganized "detonation" — we want it to be predictable, not chaotic. But if an engine can control a typical cycle with enough precision to produce steady power, it can also control detonations. And the burst of pressure that a detonation produces can result in a more efficient engine, if it\’s harnessed correctly. Typically, an engine mixes air with fuel to prepare it for detonation, which is when the fuel releases its energy. The efficiency of the fuel\’s energy release, though, is highly dependent on the type of engine.
This is where the rotating detonation engine differs from more common types of gas turbine engines. The air and fuel are mixed (as usual) before they\’re injected into a long, circular combustion chamber, in what "Physics Today" has described as "a sequential, circular manner." The first detonation sets off a cycle in which the pressure from ignition continues around the chamber, lighting each injection in sequence. The pressure from each ignition keeps the cycle moving. The pressure then forces the exhaust gas out of the combustion chamber through an exhaust nozzle, which is actually the thrust generated by the engine, and moves on to power whatever type of vehicle the engine is installed in (in this case, typically, a ship or an airplane).
The rotating detonation engine is actually a variation of another engine design: the pulse detonation wave engine. Though pulse detonation engines provide energy savings over many other types of engines, they still have their own inefficiencies. One reason is the combustion chamber which must be purged after each pulse. The rotating detonation engine is an improvement over the pulsing design, because the detonation wave constantly cycles around the chamber, eliminating the need to waste time and energy by purging.
Because detonations create extreme pressures, a detonation engine can be designed without the additional compressor that\’s usually required. Not only are compressors typically complex, but their operation generally sucks up a lot of energy, too. However, adding a compressor to a detonation engine actually makes it even more efficient. This compatibility makes it easier to retrofit gas-turbine engine vehicles to be used with detonation engine technology [source: Green Car Congress].
\”\”Retrofitting existing Navy ships, like the guided missile destroyer USS Arleigh Burke (DDG 51) shown here, with rotating detonation engine technology could result in millions of dollars in savings each year.Courtesy of U.S. Navy, photo by Journalist 2nd Class Patrick Reilly
The United States Navy is getting all the credit for its recent investment in the technology (and perking up the news cycle), but the rotating detonation engine has actually been in the works for a few decades, at this point. The patent for the engine was filed in 1982 and granted in 1988 to a Rockville, Md.-based inventor named Shmuel Eidelman. (The patent is actually called the "rotary detonation engine," rather than "rotating" — it\’s unclear when the moniker changed.)
Shmuel Eidelman has been a busy man. He has been awarded 14 patents since 1982, focusing on aeronautics, propulsion and chemicals through his work with scientific corporations and military organizations [source: PatentBuddy]. So when the patent was filed, it seemed like the Navy had pushed the gas-turbine as far as it could go, and it was time to start thinking fresh.
The U.S. Navy was initially interested in pulse detonation engines (as described earlier), and invested in research to develop these fuel-saving systems. The Navy\’s researchers say that maximizing the potential of this type of engine relies on understanding its complex physics [source: U.S. Naval Research Laboratory]. The rotating detonation engine is still a gas-turbine engine, like the engines currently powering the Navy\’s fleet of ships and aircraft, but tweaking and refining the cycle unlocks a lot of additional power. Navy researchers believe that rotating detonation engines have the potential to reduce fuel consumption in new equipment by 25 percent, which would be an annual savings of about $300 to $400 million [source: Quick]. Another benefit of the system is that it could be configured to power up an electric motor, which would, in theory, allow military fleets to start transitioning to (potentially) cleaner, cheaper and more efficient electric drivetrains.
Rotating detonation engines aren\’t ready to go just yet, so simulations are the best predictor of their efficiency — yet they\’re still promising enough that the Navy is pushing forward with development. There\’s no publicly-known ETA for completion or implementation, but the rotating detonation engine is likely to arrive — someday, anyway — at a naval base near you.
Lots More Information
Author\’s Note: How the Rotating Detonation Engine Works
It doesn\’t appear anyone\’s suggested (not yet, anyway) that the rotating detonation engine might actually have potential to be used in cars or trucks. It was invented by a guy who specialized in military technology and is being pushed into development by the U.S. Navy. The actual size of the engine model in development hasn\’t been mentioned anywhere, so this is all speculation. But we do know this: It\’s obviously big enough to power ships and planes, and that\’s way more power than a car needs. Where would the efficiency be in that?
But years of writing about cars and transportation technology has shown me that a lot of the stuff we use every day was originally developed for completely different purposes — and race cars and military vehicles are two common sources. Even though fuel-efficient cars are currently going in a different direction (hybrids, electrics and biofuels), it\’s not incomprehensible to say that someday, someone could find a way to scale down a super-efficient gas-turbine engine and stuff it under the hood of a car.
- How an Atkinson Cycle Engine Works
- How Car Engines Work
- How the Hüttlin Spherical Engine Works
- How Rotary Engines Work
- How Stirling Engines Work
- How the Tesla Turbine Works
- How the Wave Disk Generator Works
- Google Patents. "Patent US4741154 — Rotary detonation engine." (Feb. 17, 2013) http://www.google.com/patents/US4741154
- Green Car Congress. "Navy researchers project Rotating Detonation-Wave Engines could yield 10 percent power gain, 25 percent reduction in fuel burn over gas turbines." Nov. 2, 2012. (Feb. 13, 2013) http://www.greencarcongress.com/2012/11/rdwe-20121102.html
- PatentBuddy. "Eidelman, Shmuel." 2013. (Feb. 17, 2013) http://www.patentbuddy.com/Inventor/Eidelman-Shmuel/11310789
- Physics Today. "US Navy developing rotating detonation engine." Nov. 6, 2012. (Feb. 13, 2013) http://blogs.physicstoday.org/newspicks/2012/11/us-navy-developing-rotating-detonation-engine/
- Quick, Darren. "U.S. Navy investigates use of fuel-saving Rotating Detonation Engines." Gizmag.com. Nov. 4, 2012. (Feb. 13, 2013) http://www.gizmag.com/us-navy-nrl-rotating-detonation-engine/24862/
- U.S. Naval Research Laboratory. "Navy Researchers Look to Rotating Detonation Engines to Power the Future." Nov. 2, 2012. (Feb. 13, 2013) http://www.nrl.navy.mil/media/news-releases/2012/Navy-Researchers-Look-to-Rotating-Detonation-Engines-to-Power-the-Future